|#1 by beliar|
2018-11-03 at 16:00
|... stop tagging VNs you haven't yourself personally played, Seniorblitz?!|
Just looking at the tags you added to the recently created Where It All Began entry, most of them are abjectly wrong. You added tags like "Ponytail Protagonist" or "Protagonist with a Face", most likely because of the last screenshot. It's just that the person shown in that screenshot is not the protagonist, which shows why tagging the VNs based on screens alone is a folly. You also added incest tags, but the game in its current build has no incest.
It would be very much appreciated if you stop doing that, as I gather other games tagged by you also have incorrect tags.
|#2 by seniorblitz|
2018-11-03 at 16:58
|'Kay mate, sorry just kind did it on impulse kek, I'll revoke the incorrect tags, if you know any other VN I tagged incorrectly, notify me.|
|#3 by kominara|
2018-11-03 at 22:34
|here's a couple i've noticed:|
- Your tags on WarioDate were all sorts of wrong.
- Referring to the principal in Etsuraku no Gakuen as a heroine is a bit misleading, though that's probably more the fault of whoever made the character pages.
- Male Protagonist for a Short Time in Dies irae is a bit weird; unless I'm mistaken, the tag should only be applied when the main protagonist is female.
- I've already gone over my problems with your abuse of the Modifications tag.
that's all i care to dig up
|#4 by seniorblitz|
2018-11-04 at 01:43
|About the M.protag for a short time, I don't really know, I think It still applies If the temporary protag is another male character, different from the main lead, but I digress.|
Also waddya mean abuse of the mod tags? Both Melty Blood and DDLC have modifications.
|#5 by leery|
2018-11-15 at 06:15
This sort of thing makes me doubt your tags.
|#6 by kominara|
2018-11-15 at 07:18
|#4 Look at the description again; the “supports” part is what’s important.|
|#7 by seniorblitz|
2018-11-15 at 12:46
|#5 I actually have a reason why I upvoted This, after searching some of the guides to the game seem to imply the game having actual routes, even calling them as such like this one:link|
But It may been a misuderstanding on my part anyway.
#6 Again does DDLC have mod support? I even found a mod toolkit online, doesn't these mean that It applies? It would even fit the description "Supports and contains" modifications, unless I'm missing something.Last modified on 2018-11-15 at 12:46
|#8 by namingmegently|
2018-11-23 at 14:08
|Stop upvoting redundant tags that you just saw downvoted.. Female Protagonist and Simulation Game are already covered by Otome Game and Dating Simulation for Dandelion ~Neoege Buneun Baram~.|
|#9 by seniorblitz|
2018-11-23 at 16:06
|Oh yeah Otome game is a child tag of female protagonist apparently, tou downvoting It in the current state won't do much since a lot of people already upvoted It but eh whatever do your thing I guess.|
|#10 by beliar|
2018-11-26 at 19:41
|I suffered in silence, but I have to finally speak. You are using the tag Pre-rendered Backgrounds completely incorrectly. The tag is supposed to only be used when only the backgrounds are rendered, while other techniques are used for character or CG creation. You are tagging all rendered works with this tag, but they are already covered under the Pre-rendered 3D Graphics tag. Not only that, but a large percentage of those games use full renders, meaning there are no backgrounds at all, and all screens are pure CGs. Please start removing this tag from all incorrectly applied games, or I'll use my mod privileges to nullify them.|
Additionally, I noticed even more incorrect tags under some games. For example, why have you tagged Jessica O'Neil's Hard News with Heroine with Glasses, Journalist Heroine, Adult Heroine? This game has a female protagonist, and these are already protagonist tags present. While it is indicated the protag may have bisexual tendencies, there is no heroine with glasses or journalist heroine yet.
Once in your life start using your common sense and stop tagging the games you haven't played!
|#11 by seniorblitz|
2018-11-26 at 19:46
|'Kay bel, my mistakes, sorry. Though I don't remember half of the games I mistaged, so if you don't see me revoking feel free to downvote 'em (if I run into any of them I'll revoke ofc), anyway I'll stop being so impulsive and do my research at least.|
|#12 by beliar|
2018-11-26 at 20:13
|Simply go through the list with the tag Pre-rendered 3D Graphics and see if there is also a Pre-rendered Backgrounds tag added. If you see it, remove it.|
Now admittedly there are some games where the tags can overlap, but I don't think you realize the distinction.Last modified on 2018-11-26 at 20:17
|#13 by leery|
2018-11-27 at 07:49
|I totally appreciate you, beliar, for making senorblitz do more work than necessary, so I probably shouldn't speak up here, but...|
|#14 by seniorblitz|
2018-11-27 at 12:50
|Some of 'em overlap with 3DCG since they have pre-rendered sprites, others have pre-rendered backgrounds, and I already revoked the wrong ones, and If I missed any beliar can just downvote or contact me again. Also "(...)appreciate you, beliar, for marking seniorblitz do more work than necessary(...)" Sadist much leery kek? Not like his pointing a gun to my head and saying "do It" he just asked my to fix my mishaps.Last modified on 2018-11-27 at 12:51|
|#15 by seniorblitz|
2018-11-29 at 21:47
|Ataegina actually has pre-rendered sprites and backgrounds It overlaps with 3DCG, just stating this before this whole ordeal starts all over again kek.|
|#16 by beliar|
2018-11-29 at 22:24
|Actually, some of the backgrounds are rendered and some are photographs, and some are actually composites of renders and photographs.|
By the way, I think it's redundant to use Pre-rendered Backgrounds in Pre-rendered 3D Graphics games, as the latter tag covers both aspects. Even if the game is not using full renders, the overlap is not necessary. I'm even thinking of updating the Pre-rendered Backgrounds description that the tag shouldn't be used for games where other visual elements like sprites and CGs are also rendered.
It's the same as the situation, where the Otome Game tag already covers the Female Protagonist tag as #8 already stated.
|#17 by seniorblitz|
2018-11-29 at 23:58
|Feel free to do so, gonna revoke it then.|
|#18 by beliar|
2019-01-30 at 21:28
|Sigh. There is a reason I haven't marked any of the characters in Monsters of the Sea as a protagonist, Seniorblitz. The game follows a few different characters and has a third person narration, hence I'm not sure if any of the tags you have added, like Protagonist's Sister as a Heroine, Male Protagonist, Protagonist with a Face can be considered correct. I think it's better to remove them, as they kinda create false expectations. If anything, Emilia is the one we follow through the most of the game, hence "female protagonist" would be "more correct", but even then I'm not sure if that tag should be added.|
Edit: By comparing with the two follow-up games, I think it makes most sense to tag the game with "Multiple Protagonists" after all. So, the tags kinda fit now.Last modified on 2019-01-31 at 00:21
|#19 by seniorblitz|
2019-01-31 at 03:42
|Oh okay, I assumed the MC was the 'Nino' character because of the description.|
You must be logged in to reply to this thread.