Flagging Images

Posted in

#51 by shining17
2020-03-27 at 20:29
It is, if you ask me.
#52 by beliar
2020-03-27 at 20:38
Depends, but I would say no.
#53 by savagetiger
2020-03-27 at 22:56
And now I get when that guy was asking for an 'extreme' flag, it just feels wierd tagging that kind of stuff as 'tame'.
#54 by horrorizer
2020-03-28 at 06:13
there is a problem is the definition of "Explicit" in the guide
1.3. Explicit

Explicit images are the ones that could be easily considered pornographic in their content. Performing any and all sexual acts that involve genitals or penetration goes here, regardless how well dressed the characters doing them are.

The lack of clothing alone can only make an image explicit if it shows naked female nipples or naked genitalia (as a general rule of thumb: if the latter is exposed enough to be hit by the Japanese mosaic censorship, it's explicit).

it says only exposed female nipples will be always considered “explicit”, there are several problems with this
1. (traps) we all know that this cute guys every one of us likes. Their nipples are not considered explicit?
2. Sometimes is just impossible do know if a character is male or female if you don’t know that source material
3. Even when is obvious when a character is a male (can be manly woman) why would their nipples not be considered explicit material as female nipples? That’s plain sexism (this may be stretching because some cities consider boobs as something sexual that need to be censored)
Now my personal opinion is that exposed nipples should be in the “Suggestive” flag don’t matter the genre, that’s the fix the guidelines and the popup message while flagging “Explicit”
#55 by eacil
2020-03-28 at 07:30
HAHAHAHAHAHA! It's sexist to not flag men's nipples. From which country are you writing to say such ludicrous things? Jupiter?Last modified on 2020-03-31 at 20:27
#56 by some-guy
2020-03-28 at 07:39
#54 exposed male nipples are pretty common in character designs without any sexual context and therefore hardly falls into the sexual category. It's always been that way in reality as well, hence you see men walk around with naked upper bodies on the beach while women don't. Same goes with sports like MMA. Doesn't make much sense to consider a male boxer with no shirt sexual for some sort of weird anti-sexism campaign. A woman with the same outfit will definitely be considered sexualized since it's not common to expose their breasts (at least not in a single country I know of).

You will always have images that cross borders (e.g. I had an image with a wet shirt girl where you could see her boobs completely, but through clothes - is this now suggestive or explicit?), but so far it looks like multiple votes will find a solution for those. Usually it's very obvious by other aspects of the image either way - poses, backgrounds, the remaining clothing etc. can easily direct something away or into a sexual context.Last modified on 2020-03-28 at 07:40
#57 by harleyquin
2020-03-29 at 04:38
Unsure if it's related to this flagging feature, but the website loads much slower than previously. The bottleneck appears to be the image files in the thumbnails.
#58 by ikkitsuu
2020-03-29 at 06:23
It's fantastic to use one-number shortcut. I'm getting to love this voluntary work.
#59 by rampaa
2020-03-29 at 15:40
link, link

I think Yorhel is trolling the new image flagging system. :/
#60 by beliar
2020-03-29 at 15:44
Oh, Yorhel, you dog ;-)
#61 by yorhel
2020-03-29 at 15:51
You didn't see that.

(Fortunately, such mistakes will be pretty easy to find with more votes and the right queries :)
(But really, how did that happen...)

EDIT: Beliar, you dog. :)Last modified on 2020-03-29 at 16:12
#62 by beliar
2020-03-29 at 16:16
Beliar, you dog. :)
#63 by skorpiondeath
2020-03-29 at 16:22
pwnd :P
#64 by some-guy
2020-03-29 at 17:27
I swear with some images it's like a game detecting the NSFW. Took me 5 seconds to realize the Beliar example is explicit :D.
#65 by beliar
2020-03-29 at 17:37
Especially with some VN covers where you have to squint: Is that a nipple or a different coloured spot?
One advantage of this - we will be very good at playing "Spot ten differences" after going through the image flagging gauntlet.
#66 by wakaranai
2020-03-29 at 18:28
some usability nitpick: in my browser (brave, chrome-based) when radio button control has a focus it has its own keyboard shortcuts that override arrow keys behavior, making them switch between radio buttons. i didn't realize that right away and may have flagged some images incorrectly without noticing. is it possible to force arrow keys to always jump to next/prev images regardless of focus?

EDIT: it behaves even worse, arrow keys both switch radio button AND make jump to other image, rendering previous one incorrectly tagged. again, this happens only when radio button control has a focus.Last modified on 2020-03-29 at 18:32
#67 by eacil
2020-03-29 at 19:40
Is it normal behavior that you can bypass the RNG? I mean, I can choose what I want to vote on.Last modified on 2020-03-29 at 19:44
#68 by beliar
2020-03-29 at 20:33
You mean, to skip an image? Yes, that is intended behaviour.
#69 by mrkew
2020-03-29 at 20:44
link - I don't think some people understand "No (implied) sexual actions", because this is clearly a cropped H-scene.
#70 by eacil
2020-03-29 at 20:52
Beliar, I mean that you give me any cover/character/CG and I can vote on it. You just have to look at the pics shared here.
#71 by rampaa
2020-03-29 at 20:55
@eacil: t13727.13
Mods can do it already
#72 by eacil
2020-03-29 at 21:00
Me thought I was a suupaa hakkaa. :(Last modified on 2020-03-29 at 21:03
#73 by wakaranai
2020-03-29 at 21:41
@69 you should judge image as it is, without meta-knowledge of the related VN. in this case sexual action would be implied if there were any signs of her partner present. as it is image is safe by definition.
#74 by jazz957
2020-03-29 at 21:43
Help. I'm addicted. 5000 images flagged and somehow only one guro image (and let me tell you it was pretty bad).Last modified on 2020-03-29 at 21:47
#75 by mrkew
2020-03-29 at 21:48
There is no meta knowledge related. I did not know the game before seeing the picture. Her face is twisted in pleasure.