VN with the ugliest heroine?

Posted in

#1 by zakashi
2021-10-15 at 20:32
< report >Is there any VN with an ugly heroine? Which one is the ugliest?
#2 by historyeraser
2021-10-15 at 20:46
< report >Do you mean characters literally drawn to look ugly? Like with visible acne or do you mean subjectively?
#3 by zakashi
2021-10-15 at 21:00
< report >Either option is fine. Characters designed to be ugly according to plot, and characters you just find ugly overall.

But I'm personally more interested in finding characters designed to be ugly.
#4 by Mutsuki
2021-10-15 at 21:05
< report >yikes i can't wait till an argument breaks out between someone who posts a heroine and someone who thinks that's their favourite heroine
#5 by kratoscar2008
2021-10-15 at 21:27
< report >A better question is if said heroine should be romanceable or not.
You get a bunch of ugly heroines but are side characters meant to be ugly.
#6 by plisken
2021-10-15 at 21:42
< report >Best be careful. Say the wrong thing and some moron will come in and start white-knighting about "body shaming".
#7 by kratoscar2008
2021-10-15 at 22:00
< report >Im out of shape and ugly so its fine.
#8 by masturbator
2021-10-15 at 22:37
< report >this is a very difficult question you have posed zakashi as i cannot recall the last time i saw a girl (let alone heroine) in a vn who i thought was ugly

meanwhile we could probably think of so many contenders if the question was "VN with the ugliest hero?"

#7 (kratoscar2008)
that description fits me as well though this is not really relevant to the threadLast modified on 2021-10-15 at 22:42
#9 by netorious
2021-10-15 at 22:43
< report >Sakuragawa Hitomi is ugly-cute
#10 by masturbator
2021-10-15 at 22:53
< report >can we get an ugly heroine who:

a) is from an 18+ game


b) is not fat
#11 by historyeraser
2021-10-15 at 23:21
< report >#9

>Posting protagonists
#12 by zakashi
2021-10-15 at 23:45
< report >@8 I'm well aware of that due to the very nature of these games, who wants to date ugly girls? It makes no sense to create ugly heroines (?).

At least at first, maybe some VN creator perceived this and thought "what if I create ugly heroines? What original of me", therefore some ugly girls were born. I read a lot of games and I'm yet to see a heroine who is not treated as a "perfect hot goddess" In-Universe, protagonists is another story, a lot of them are written as your "average bland guy" who gets hot girls, but it's still a little bit rare to see the ugly ones, without the same level of "rareness" of ugly heroines. (But just sayin, there should be a lot more hot MCs, because I am a hot guy in real life, so I can't self-insert in a bland dude)

But you can post also girls who you just think is ugly, without any in-story justification xDLast modified on 2021-10-15 at 23:49
#13 by eiesoldar
2021-10-16 at 00:50
< report >Some Fuusen Club 's heroines have very questionable look (like Kagura Saeko, Ragawa Yui Maie Miya )
#14 by danteas
2021-10-16 at 00:53
< report >finding a visualy ugly heroine its probably imposible if you guys want to exclude fat heroines, since people dont want to see them, the fat ones are made to catter to very niche fetishes.
the closest to what op wants i can think of is link , who is suposed to be ugly but hides it under layers of make up, and to be honest we never really see her actual face.
if you want heroines who are genuinelly ugly when it comes to personality, a good example is
link she is for me the most realistic yandere (that doesnt go in murder territory) i have ever found, showing me that irl yanderes are not worthLast modified on 2021-10-16 at 00:54
#15 by zakashi
2021-10-16 at 01:27
< report >I don't see the need to exclude fat girls.Last modified on 2021-10-16 at 01:37
#16 by masturbator
2021-10-16 at 02:00
< report >Debutopia has fat heroines

#12 (zakashi)

But just sayin, there should be a lot more hot MCs, because I am a hot guy in real life, so I can't self-insert in a bland dude

it is the opposite with me...need an overweight mc who preferably has a small penisLast modified on 2021-10-16 at 02:00
#17 by irehi
2021-10-16 at 04:09
< report >#16 Valkyria always does really weird shit... And yeah I think it will be difficult to find purposefully ugly heroines, we may find ugly art but nothing beyond thatLast modified on 2021-10-16 at 04:30
#18 by Ileca
2021-10-16 at 04:56
< report >Aren't every character drawn by Hinoue Itaru designed to be ugly? Because, oh boy, they do are ugly.
#19 by tomtheerogeman
2021-10-16 at 05:19
< report >Umm, I won't respond to anyone who loses their shit at me, but for the sake of fun and killing time here's a few heroines from my past games I thought would make it on an ugly list:

Takahara Minako I know eacil disagrees, but I'm adding Taka because a majority of men here won't find her attractive. Highly unlikely you can sit there and argue otherwise.
Sarita Noriko Same reason as Taka above, muscles.
Kiryuu Sarasa Hair's too big for my liking, and curls like that don't really fit IMO.
Mibu Natsume Eyes are too far apart, looks crosseyed in the picture.
Ootori Chihaya Don't be fooled by her picture, I think that's Chihaya's beta sprite because her real one in game is different: link . It's mostly her uniform that I think is ugly and not so much her, and I got pissed when the teacher said they don't have a uniform to replace her old one. Like how thick does a necktie have to be for the very front layer of fabric to spill out of her top like that? I could never stop staring at that when I played it back in 2013.
Daidouji Karin Huge hair, almost the same color as her skin. I know Musumaker's heroines are named after fruits, but it was hard to get over the idea that their looks had to follow this theme as well.
Shinomiya Tsukiyo Similar hair color, normally I don't mind ponytails but just think about this for a second: her ponytail is so thin that you can tell most strands of her hair aren't tied back. But the rest of her hair is short, so why is her ponytail hair so long? What were they thinking?

As for VNs I didn't read, the sequel Sensei Da-isuki 2 's heroines look questionable, and I think this pic takes the cake: link . If I see as many crazy ass references as the first game's Japanese description I might actually read it one day, but probably not likely.
#20 by historyeraser
2021-10-16 at 05:23
< report >#18

Like this chick: Takano Midori
#21 by bobjr2000
2021-10-16 at 14:24
< report >Interesting topic to me as I prefer more realistic or natural looking women instead of Jessica Rabbit type or 12 year old teenagers with big boobs.

link I don't think she is ugly but really hated that they changed her look during common route. She looks very similar to another heroine in beginning of game but then gets make over and everyone thinks she is hot stuff when I thought she looks like a 50s bad make over.

Edelweiss- Honestly most of characters are drawn pretty weird and don't look that feminine imo. I don't hate it but also doesn't really peak my interest either for most them which is usually my big appeal to purse a vn or not.
#22 by butterflygrrl
2021-10-16 at 15:12
< report >It's tricky because the ugliest heroines are usually that way because I just hate the artist's art style to begin with, which is nothing to do with whether teh character is supposed to be ugly. Anime art styles usually give everyone a generic 'acceptable' appearance which makes it hard to understand characters sometimes when they complain that one of them is plain or one is especially pretty. It's mostly an informed attribute.

Most characters with extremely huge breasts are going to fall into my 'wow that's ugly' category because it personally repels me, but does that actually make them ugly heroines?

Oomori Nanako is especially bad, for me.
#23 by pancakebutter
2021-10-16 at 15:24
< report >Tamura Chihaya
#24 by barfboy
2021-10-18 at 08:43
< report >A joke character and not a heroine so it doesn't apply but I'll post her anyway.
#25 by elijahbeaudoin
2021-10-18 at 09:52
< report >Trying to check every tag that might lead to "ugly" and came across this:
But only in 1 or 2 scenes in a game I've never heard of.