Regarding v30334

Posted in

#1 by Marc402
2022-01-29 at 16:24
< report >Some of your tags on Mukashi Mukashi no Koi Monogatari appear to be incorrect.

• You downvoted Interracial Sex and Interracial/Interspecies Romance, but the VN involves romance and sex between a human and a giant, who are of different races. The VN even mentions this multiple times.

• You applied the Rape tag even though there's just one sex scene and it's consensual. The game's official English page even explicitly mentions "Please note this is an adult-oriented title which depicts explicit, consensual sexual situations."

• You downvoted the Otome Game tag. This certainly seems like an otome title (the other voters all think so too) and the developers of this VN are known for creating otome games. Most importantly, this is also listed on DLsite in the girls' side with the Otome tag on it.

Fix your tags plz, as even one vote on the tags on obscure VNs can mess up the score or result in them being hidden.Last modified on 2022-01-29 at 16:59
#2 by beliar
2022-01-29 at 16:31
< report >Just a note, but Interracial Sex shouldn't be used for interspecies sex, so it should be downvoted in this case.
#3 by Marc402
2022-01-29 at 16:33
< report >The game specifically mentions they are of different races, not species. I also linked two images of it (link and link).
#4 by beliar
2022-01-29 at 16:40
< report >Doesn't mean the game uses the word correctly. Different races are humans of different phenotypes, while species are something that are not human. Even if the game names the giants a race, it doesn't support the actual definition and imho shouldn't be applied.
#5 by Marc402
2022-01-29 at 16:44
< report >Alright then, but the other 3 tags should still be fixed as they are very obvious.
Also, what tag should be used instead of Interracial Sex for this VN? I don't see an Interspecies sex tag, but the giant-human relationship imo is an important feature of this VN.

Edit: I actually think the game does use the word correctly. At the end of the VN they have sex and produce a baby, which is only possible with Interracial Sex, not Interspecies Sex.Last modified on 2022-01-29 at 16:45
#6 by beliar
2022-01-29 at 16:48
< report >We don't have an Interspecies Sex tag (only the combined romance one), but considering how common non-human heroes and heroines are, it's not really needed. We also don't have a Giant Hero tag under Non-human Hero, because giants are not very popular as heroes, and it's not worth creating a tag just for one VN.

Edit:
At the end of the VN they have sex and produce a baby
Well, Asari can also make children with humans, but they are decidedly different species. Sci-fi/fantasy logic.Last modified on 2022-01-29 at 16:49

Reply

You must be logged in to reply to this thread.