Candidates for deletion

Posted in

#2801 by eacil
2019-06-09 at 21:11
r63901 is a duplicate of r61125.
r39010 seems to be dead.
#2802 by lunaterra
2019-06-11 at 01:28
Same as it Ever Was cancelled link
#2803 by warfoki
2019-06-11 at 21:05
Koredemo ka! Hentai Anal Zukushi
Koredemo ka! Hentai Ahegao Zukushi
Kore demo ka! Hentai Fellatio Zukushi 2

These are not separate visual novels, just collections of thematic scenes from the previous titles of the circle. Similar to the Lilith-Izm titles. As such I added the releases originally under these entries to the relevant titles as partial, which makes these VN entries redundant.Last modified on 2019-06-11 at 21:10
#2804 by eacil
2019-06-11 at 21:17
Izm are not collections of stock scenes they plundered from their previous titles, they are legit fandisks (that's why they have separate entries).
To cut your nukige in pieces and fit some bits into a box might be the lamest marketing move ever done to VN.
Or I didn't understand at all what those releases were and they truly are like Izm (but I recognized the CG used on the covers).
#2805 by warfoki
2019-06-11 at 21:33
Okay, Izms weren't the best example there. And yeah, these are literally just scenes from previous titles copied wholesale and sold. Anywhere from 3 to 10 titles per collection are copied from.
#2806 by mysterycorgi
2019-06-12 at 07:39
Sick Dreams was cancelled and Secret Cards was dissolved. Eight8Diamonds, LovesickJackal, Khoven are not making visual novels at this time and have not worked on any other titles. As for the source, I'm a member of the now dead team (Mystery Corgi but I'm still active so don't delete please), so...first hand source? The project died a long while back and I only just noticed that it was still here. Thanks.
#2807 by [deleted]
2019-06-12 at 07:51
^ VN entries don't get deleted unless nothing public is released; since Sick Dreams has a demo, even if it's no longer available, it should stay. I'll add a note about the cancellation, though.
#2808 by mysterycorgi
2019-06-12 at 08:44
^ Appreciated! Also I forgot about the demo being released, thank you for the clarification.
#2809 by trickzzter
2019-06-13 at 03:44
deleledLast modified on 2019-06-14 at 02:11
#2810 by fuukanou
2019-06-14 at 12:31
link

Double post of the same game.
#2811 by traumatizer
2019-06-14 at 14:52
dupe from me not checking things properly
#2812 by warfoki
2019-06-16 at 11:29
I don't think that Bully Girl => Sex Slave (Motion Comic Version) actually qualifies as a visual novel. I wanted to add more info, as the entry lacked publisher, website, anything as a source, so I looked into it a bit. It's a 20 minute long hentai video, or as the site calls it, animated comic. Which is pretty accurate, they added some simple, looping animations and voice acting on top of teh original CG-set and made it into a 20 min video. Narration is minimal, if you can call it even that, it's basically just a low-spec hentai video with hardcoded subtitles.

I've found the full video here for reference.

If it indeed gets deleted, p-kan can go as well, it's the artist for the original CG set that got animated. I added him just for this, as far as I could see he's not associated with any actual visual novels.
#2813 by fuukanou
2019-06-16 at 16:36
link

OELVN from new author that hasn't even got a demo yet. Isn't this against the rules?
#2814 by shining17
2019-06-16 at 16:53
A lot of VNs with "TBA" status and no demo are also listed here though; even the Japanese ones.
#2815 by [deleted]
2019-06-16 at 17:23
^ TBA releases are only an issue if they're from creators with no previous history of finished projects, especially in the case of free doujin projects because they're frequently announced and then abandoned. This tends to only be an issue with English VNs, because random Japanese VNs from unknown creators tend to not be added to the database even if they're finished, let alone if they're just TBA.

Love Live! The Visual Novel Project! does have an in-progress build available to download on the itch.io page, so I'm inclined to give it a pass for the moment, but other mods should weigh in.
#2816 by beliar
2019-06-16 at 17:48
I'm giving Love Live! The Visual Novel Project! a pass, due to the source code available on Itch.io.

As for Bully Girl => Sex Slave (Motion Comic Version)... If that's all there is to that, then it really sounds more like a short animated movie more than a VN.
#2817 by warfoki
2019-06-16 at 17:58
Considering that according to DLsite the entire thing is a 253 MB MPEG file, I highly doubt there's more to it. Also, these animated CG-sets are a dime in a dozen on DLsite, so if we give this a pass, we are opening the database for potentially hundreds of entries like this.
#2818 by beliar
2019-06-16 at 19:04
I agree. The game has been deleted.
#2819 by augustino
2019-06-17 at 17:57
r63375 is a duplicate of r59914
No reason specified why it was forked off r59914.4 (steam release?)
#2820 by eacil
2019-06-17 at 20:30
It's no duplicate, if you look at the VN page, one is all-age steam garbage and the other one is 18+.Last modified on 2019-06-19 at 21:10
#2821 by kiru
2019-06-19 at 12:34
Saki Achiga-hen episode of Side-A Portable seems to not have any story whatsoever. I'm not exactly familiar with the gameplay itself, so I can't test past it, but from the looks of the official website, there's nothing I'm missing. And let's be honest, which game starts gameplay matches without a single line of dialogue, if there is any?
#2822 by rampaa
2019-06-21 at 02:26
link is dupe of link
#2823 by harleyquin
2019-06-22 at 13:43
link.

Not a voiced character. These are the "generic" enemies seen throughout the game and don't warrant an individual character entry when it's a whole horde of them in different shapes and sizes.
#2824 by xg70d
2019-06-23 at 13:12
I accidentally added a duplicate VA, so please delete s18704.1. Sorry, and thank you in advance.Last modified on 2019-06-23 at 13:13
#2825 by harleyquin
2019-06-29 at 07:23
link

Graphics localization is one thing, but if the text translation is machine-run doesn't this disqualify this entry (and all other entries like this) from the database?

Reply

You must be logged in to reply to this thread.