Candidates for deletion

Posted in

#2026 by lunaterra
2017-07-06 at 00:54
Adyrn alias of Helen Rachael Morris
#2027 by usagi
2017-07-07 at 07:47
Beskonechnyj holod
I think modifications are not needed here. There are literally hundreds mods for this novel - if we allow it here, we should allow all extra scenarios for MGQ, for example, as separate entries as well 0_0 Maybe as new release type if mod is large enough is more appropriate.. I don't know..
P.S.: I've just created special tag for them Modifications - I think it should be enough. .. How long this moderation queue will be? 0_0Last modified on 2017-07-07 at 08:05
#2028 by trickzzter
2017-07-08 at 13:40
Please remove this redundant entry link
It'll be a multi-language release, so I just added Czech language into the English version link
#2029 by origin
2017-07-11 at 00:17
r47869 dead official site, translation will not be
#2030 by 707
2017-07-11 at 07:57
r52496

because the person who created the xbox version decided not to put the publisher and i created a duplicate while in producer's page

Nishimashi Maako Amai Ringo these are aliases. should've checked beforehand, my badLast modified on 2017-07-14 at 08:34
#2031 by shinnew
2017-07-15 at 08:21
Muv-Luv Photonflowers* and Muv-Luv Photonmelodies♮.

Collection of stories that were already included in previous releases with no original content, I don't think they should have their own VN entries.

Making the Japanese version a partial release of the original VNs is simple enough but there is a problem with the upcoming English bundles (r43062, r43353, r43532)

You can't set them as partial releases since they contain a complete Muv-Luv and Muv-Luv Alternative but marking it as complete would make it look like they contain a complete version of the VNs the stories are originally from.


Waiting for opinions about what to do with these entries.
#2032 by kiru
2017-07-15 at 09:54
Given that it's a full game sold, I'm not so hot about the partial here either, especially as it's a console release of stuff that had no console version before. In other words, the stuff it doesn't contain of whatever it ported is not available on consoles.

I feel it'd get too messy to kill these entries and trying to settle it with releases. Then again, Muvluv is generally messy...
#2033 by wakaranai
2017-07-15 at 21:43
Hino Ataru alias of Fukazu Tomoyoshi -- link
#2034 by harleyquin
2017-07-18 at 01:31
link

I've played this and don't think it should be here. Sex scenes are narrated, but most of the game is about RPG turn-based battles.

Crimson games tend to follow the same format which is probably why only a small selection of the circle's games are listed here.
#2035 by bokkusu
2017-07-18 at 23:57
link

I made this earlier seeing it on link, but no release entry was there when I checked the 0verflow website.
#2036 by harleyquin
2017-07-21 at 01:36
link

So it's allowed on this database? Previously when this game came up I said it was mostly RPG with no combat. Only the sex scenes resemble anything close to the criteria for a VN.
#2037 by beliar
2017-07-21 at 05:37
Not so much "allowed", as someone jumped the gun and added the game without thinking much.
While I haven't played the game, I remember you mentioning that it's not a VN on that other thread, so I'll have to trust your judgement and delete the entry.
#2038 by trickzzter
2017-07-21 at 05:57
What do you think about Unhack?
It's a puzzle game with VN-style dialogues. The only part of the game that has narration is an ending of the last level/episode.

There is a demo version if you want to check it by yourself: linkLast modified on 2017-07-21 at 06:05
#2039 by kight099
2017-07-23 at 05:11
Konrinya: duplicate of Kon Rinya.
#2040 by 707
2017-07-24 at 20:50
r47508

the game language is changeable, so i added japanese to the english entryLast modified on 2017-07-24 at 20:50
#2041 by trickzzter
2017-07-26 at 02:52
So what about Unhack? Because I don't see how it can be considered a VN by VNDB standards.
#2042 by kominarachromer
2017-07-26 at 03:20
The website calls it a VN very clearly. If the creator themselves says it's a VN, it should probably be on the database.
#2043 by lunaterra
2017-07-26 at 04:10
VNDB has its own standards for what makes a VN, which may or may not reflect individual creators' definitions of a visual novel. I've played loads of "RPG/visual novels" that turned out to just be dialogue-heavy RPGs.

I haven't played the game in question, so idk whether it's a VN, I just wanted to point out that what the creator says isn't particularly relevant here.
#2044 by trickzzter
2017-07-26 at 04:35
You can watch the whole game on youtube:
Part 1: link
Part 2: link
Part 3: link
Part 4: link
#2045 by traumatizer
2017-07-26 at 14:09
Accidental dupe.
#2046 by kight099
2017-07-26 at 22:51
I don't think there're anyone named Hoka. If there are, sucks to be them.
#2047 by gregx
2017-07-27 at 06:17
r45528 cancelled.
#2048 by alto
2017-07-31 at 21:58
I went blind and somehow added dupe r52857
#2049 by asaki
2017-08-02 at 03:07
I think the mods could delete these two seiyuu entry (Koura Ryouji and Kitani Kazusa) since turned out they're just aliases for both of Fukushima Jun and Yamamoto Nozomi respectively. Thanks in advance.

PS - Just check Wagahigh edit log if you need proofLast modified on 2017-08-02 at 03:10
#2050 by shinnew
2017-08-02 at 08:12
Can you also post a proper source for this edit? link

The official website link credits "桐ノ小島翼" not "中村 繪里子" (Nakamura Eriko) and this name does not appear in the list of aliases you posted. Can you post a source that they are the same person?

Reply

You must be logged in to reply to this thread.