Candidates for deletion

Posted in

#2326 by alexlung
2018-05-14 at 05:15
@yorhel, you may delete Saimin Kizoku as well thats all i asked if thats what the mods wants
#2327 by harleyquin
2018-05-14 at 06:02
Saimin Kizoku = Saimin Kizoku.

Only added here because it was sold on Steam and get more press than it otherwise would have being on Dlsite and DMM.
#2328 by alexlung
2018-05-14 at 06:21
Well, I looked it up and searched The Nobleman's Retort, Kanji as well and found no link regarding steam?

May I asked what's the name of the game on steam release kindly

Honestly, even if it was sold on steam I don't think it matters regarding to it being deleted.

It's literally the same thing as XVI ~Liz of the Tower, if you checked the last discussion on Saimin you would know I am actually against of such things being on vndb

Was the same reason as Thug Hero Party, because if Saimin Kizoku was qualified to stay it makes 0 sense not to include the others as well.
#2329 by harleyquin
2018-05-14 at 06:56
I'm not in favour of RPGmaker games in this database. However, unless games which don't meet the criteria are flagged up in this thread there's no way for the overworked moderators to know what shouldn't be on this database to begin with.

My mistake. It seems the game was sold on Dlsite English with some of the game in English text, not on Steam which I mistakenly assumed.Last modified on 2018-05-14 at 18:17
#2330 by alexlung
2018-05-14 at 07:13
#harleyquin, Oh i see no problem

Obviously they aren't visual novel by any means, not asking for the mods to remove all of them right now, it will take time for time. I wouldn't really call Monmusu Quest! Paradox RPG Zenshou a Visual Novel either, nor Corpse party (more like an adventure game, but the devs actually posted it as Visual Novel and on steam), but that's up to debates. I apologised for the misunderstanding earlier. Anyhow should the mods remove XVI ~Liz of the Tower~ please do the same with Saimin Kizoku

Then I won't pry any further regarding Thug Hero and such. It's clear H-RPG games aren't welcomed here by the looks of it, so obviously it would be dumb to add any more of em on vndb
#2331 by beliar
2018-05-14 at 18:06
I have been deeply suspicious of Saimin Kizoku for a while now, bet never gave myself time to check it myself, and the game hasn't been flagged by any of the users.
I swear I'll check both Saimin Kizoku and XVI ~Liz of the Tower~ during the next week or so and will remove them if applicable.
#2332 by alexlung
2018-05-14 at 22:21
Thanks for your work beliar will appreciate it
#2333 by hotsushi-kun
2018-05-15 at 23:20
Alias found
Koyama Sahomi = Komazawa Yoshika
link
#2334 by kominarachromer
2018-05-16 at 00:56
#2230 The reason for Corpse Party's inclusion is laid out fairly simply in the special cases list; besides, VNDB has a long history of allowing adventure games that aren't quite visual novels under the strictest definition of the term.

And I doubt Monmusu Quest! Paradox RPG Zenshou will ever get removed; firstly, because it's part of a series, and secondly, because it actually does have long ADV style sections and particularly lengthy and plentiful H-scenes. Hell, I'd say it belongs more than those old Rance games that lack both a visual novel style and consistent narration.
#2335 by alexlung
2018-05-16 at 09:42
@kominarachromer, yea just saw that. Well I am a big fan of Monmusu quest, so honesty I would be fine if it was here regardless.

Thug Hero Party was more or less the same, ridiculous amount of narration plus H-scenes. So I don't think even if it has a trillion amount of h scenes would help

In that case it may be more fitting to include it on special list of games regarding Monmusu quest RPG?
#2336 by savagetiger
2018-05-17 at 01:22
Heimskringla was canceled link
#2337 by trickzzter
2018-05-17 at 02:35
Ezarel's Creepy Halloween Stories dupe of Zhutkie istorii Ezarelja na Hellouin
I added it by mistake...
#2338 by 707
2018-05-17 at 14:51
Saihate ★ Frontier and its developer Clear Color Works
website dead link
probably not happening anymore
#2339 by wakaranai
2018-05-19 at 01:16
Hirabayashi Teppei alias of Kondou Takayuki - link
#2340 by hotsushi-kun
2018-05-19 at 08:40
Nabatame Hitomi = Yamato Emi as credited her real name in the anime
#2341 by alexandraidv
2018-05-19 at 16:23
r51837 - the VN's platforms have not yet been announced, and the person who created the entry for the release even wrote in their edit summary that it was just speculation. I have already changed the platform for the other release they created to unknown, so this one is now entirely superfluous.
#2342 by dk382
2018-05-19 at 21:41
Deleted r51837. Kinda sad that took a year for us to notice. Would like to remind everyone again to please refrain from speculating in the release entries. Do not add releases you think will "probably" exist, do not add release dates/windows or age ratings you think are simply likely, etc.Last modified on 2018-05-19 at 21:41
#2343 by thewayfarer
2018-05-20 at 03:12
Mary-Lee Nicks doesn't have a VN appearance for a few days. I tried googling the name but couldn't find a precise VN it appears in.Last modified on 2018-05-20 at 03:14
#2344 by savagetiger
2018-05-25 at 13:22
r52798 was in hiatus, but now the itchio is gone so not likely coming out.
#2345 by eacil
2018-05-26 at 00:15
I suspect u55140 copied r15329 (>r57082) instead of editing it.
#2346 by harleyquin
2018-05-26 at 13:42
u114150 adds an awful lot of RPG games. Just looking at the DLsite product descriptions disqualifies a lot of the entries but I don't have the time nor inclination to go through them all. Is there a watch list for users not following the inclusion rules?
#2347 by savagetiger
2018-05-27 at 04:29
New Gundam Breaker now that the games apparently out should it be deleted?
apparently whoever added it put the wrong dates.
#2348 by shinnew
2018-05-27 at 07:59
I'm not seeing it out anywhere and the official website still has the June date, can you point out where it is available?
#2349 by savagetiger
2018-05-27 at 10:19
Ah whoops, it seems like they were just talking about the previous games in general, still... any second opinion from trailers yet? Because those character entries are completely wrong but I don't want to fix them if the games gonna get deleted anyway.
#2350 by traumatizer
2018-05-28 at 14:43
Sezaikado Aoi one of Nakamura Eriko's new aliases. (link)

And Shigure Shouko's another one of Mai Gotou's. (link)Last modified on 2018-05-28 at 14:47

Reply

You must be logged in to reply to this thread.