Posted in

#2176 by gvbn
2020-07-30 at 13:12
< report >Blowbang's example pic is better suited for its child trait than the trait itself
#2177 by beliar
2020-07-30 at 15:58
< report >
Can you remove Gokkun from Group Sex?

Sexual Roleplay has been del'd for several years
I have no idea why the trait was deleted. I myself have missed its presence.

Blowbang's example pic is better suited for its child trait than the trait itself
Uploaded a better pic.
#2178 by barfboy
2020-07-31 at 17:24
< report >Mahou Shoujo can be applied to boys, yes? Just want to be sure, I see some examples already tagged so I'm going to assume everyone's okay with using it like that.

Anyway, it needs to be updated to include idol singers (like Minky Momo or Fancy Lala) and magical girl witches (Like Magical Doremi and Jewelpet Twinkle).
Idol Mahou Shoujo Chiruchiru ☆ Michiru
Ore-sama no RagnaRock
I'm not sure, never played either of them. Anyway, it's perhaps an easy fix.
#2179 by beliar
2020-07-31 at 17:39
< report >Do you mean boys that turn into magical girls? In that case it would apply.
Or do you mean boys that turn into magical boys? In that case I would say "probably no".

I think the description is ambiguous enough that I'm pretty sure we don't specifically explain that the trait can be used for magical idols or cute witch girls.
#2180 by barfboy
2020-07-31 at 17:46
< report >Fair enough, shall I make a trait for crossdressing magical boys?

It's a bit weird that the trait specifically calls out the fact that magical girls fight evil and protect the earth. The tag doesn't. Mahou Shoujo Heroine
Eh, I'm not that bothered by it, I imagine people get the difference and apply it properly either way.Last modified on 2020-07-31 at 17:47
#2181 by beliar
2020-07-31 at 18:01
< report >Well, if those boys are crossdressing to fight evil, the current trait might apply if we allow it. I misunderstood you and assumed you asked simply about magical boys without a crossdressing part. In that case I don't think we need an all-in trait: using the current Mahou Shoujo and Crossdressing traits should be enough.
#2182 by skorpiondeath
2020-07-31 at 22:52
< report >@beliar, barfboy: Mahou Shounen Hero exist too, just to remind you.
#2183 by ninius
2020-08-01 at 07:57
< report >Hi, just asking: why does it take so long for suggested traits to get moderated? I made 2 trait suggestions 2 days ago and they're still waiting. I have so many ideas for new traits but this is a bit discouraging making them.
#2184 by beliar
2020-08-01 at 11:24
< report >Because the staff are lazy assholes.
Oh, wait... -.-'
#2185 by rampaa
2020-08-02 at 03:56
< report >Off Screen Sex with Others has been denied with the following reasoning:
Denied. Imho the trait is completely useless - if it only happens off-screen, it doesn't really matter. We don't HAVE to know that it happens with someone other than the protagonist...
I would like to disagree. Off Screen Sex, depending on who the partner is, has totally different connotations. It can range anywhere from "Protagonist and the heroine had sex with each other last night as well, but we have already filled our h-scene quota, so no new scene for it" to "You know the girl who protagonist trained for the whole game? Yeah, he shared her with some dudes off screen". The latter being off screen doesn't magically make it unimportant (at least not for everyone) as you seem to suggest. Please reconsider.
#2186 by naiohoras
2020-08-04 at 09:06
< report >in Thrifty, "property" should be changed to "poverty". weird case of typo, I know... -,-''

I think it's pretty safe that Schoolmate can be made as non-applicable.

regarding Half-tie, the idea was to distinguish between this twintails and this twintails, and could be apllied to another kind of tied hairstyle. I think it could be really useful when using the character filter, and not to mention we've had several threads where people couldn't identify the VN but has a character as a clue.

Seems like a trait that will be either not used enough or overused to hell and back
while I do agree that the hairstyle is quite common on VN world, I disagree that it would be abused. common =/= overused. and last but not least... I like character who has these kind of hairstyle so to be able to distinguish it would be really help.

Also the title seems to have been completely made up by the proposer
that's mean :( I at least did a quick search on google, and the result was either "half-tie hairstyle" or "half-up half-down hairstyle".
...but I do agree the naming is a kind of unsophisticated. if anyone came with a better naming than those, that'd be very helpful.Last modified on 2020-08-04 at 09:13
#2187 by funnerific
2020-08-04 at 17:17
< report >Change Dougakunen's primary name to Same Year Student or remove this monstrosity outright (it's really specific so I'd rather you did this).Last modified on 2020-08-04 at 17:19
#2188 by goldenpincers
2020-08-04 at 21:21
< report >Same Year Student has an extra "and" in the first sentence
#2189 by goldenpincers
2020-08-04 at 21:26
< report >I actually agree with #2187. It's overly specific and doesn't add any important information to characters
#2190 by diabloryuzaki
2020-08-04 at 21:27
< report >can i ask if "schoolmate" trait is important? i mean it is important if you look it in graph mode but if you look it in profile mode it is look stupid because we have eleventh grader or something similar like this before and it is more clear

moreover if one vn have a pair or more character that have schoolmate trait but from different school, how user know the difference? i don't recommended something that can misleading user easily like this
#2191 by beliar
2020-08-04 at 22:53
< report >
It's overly specific and doesn't add any important information to characters
I don't know. We have kouhai and senpai traits. I mean, I don't think it's that important either, but I don't see much harm in having 'Same Year student' as a trait too.

can i ask if "schoolmate" trait is important?
I'd say it's important. Actually, I see all those 'grade' traits of lesser importance than Schoolmate child traits. They quickly provide basic information about school hierarchy among characters, without having to dwell into the numerical grade, which is usually not even mentioned in VNs.
#2192 by diabloryuzaki
2020-08-05 at 00:02
< report >#2191 but didn't that schoolmate become confusing if a vn have some character from different school in there like character A & B is from school X so they have schoolmate trait then character C & D is from school Y so they have same trait too. but how to see the different from user side? i find that schoolmate trait is confusing moreover if i don't see school affiliation in character description where it is not always in there of course
#2193 by naiohoras
2020-08-05 at 02:20
< report >we already have had these exact conversations that most traits are useless since we don't know which character is related to which, it's not only schoolmate guys. that's why we need that "characters' relation" feature, or just put it straight in the description for now.


You must be logged in to reply to this thread.