why this VN having really low rating

Posted in

#1 by sai30
2017-03-27 at 13:23
why this VN having really low rating, in my opinion this VN have really good story also top no 1 the best VN in this months.
#2 by yumemi-kun
2017-03-27 at 17:37
heroines routes (besides imoutos route which has some special content lol) was quite unnecessary and short, in my opinion. but the protagonist is.... um, interesting and ive liked true end a lot. some twists (like that one about the protagonists father) were quite unexpected too.

also art is extremely bad side artists were drawing better than main artist lelLast modified on 2017-04-01 at 14:03
#3 by yumemi-kun
2017-03-27 at 17:43
also i dont think that rating is too low. theres just 11 votes let more vn readers to complete it lol
#4 by kzel
2017-03-27 at 18:24
I'm personally waiting for a patch before playing this, as it seems it has a few bugs and a LOT of typos/incorrect kanji. Just a quick look at #イストリア誤字 on twitter reveals some pretty huge blunders...
#5 by yumemi-kun
2017-03-27 at 18:28
there will be no patch i guess since its just lucle's own, aaa, style? i dunno but the same thing was in his previous work, kamimaho and as you can see theres still no patch for itLast modified on 2017-03-27 at 18:28
#6 by kzel
2017-03-27 at 18:47
I don't remember that many typos in kamimaho, and it did have a patch released about a month after release -> link
#7 by yumemi-kun
2017-03-27 at 18:59
lol didnt know about that thanks ^o^
#8 by luciencren
2017-03-31 at 02:52
I played kamimaho early and it had a ridiculous amount of typos so wouldn't surprise me this is the same. I also remember the the clothes of one heroine changing like every other line once..
#9 by bdawg
2017-04-02 at 08:44
There was one scene in the imouto-Yurugi route where 2 Yurugi sprites appears in same screen (one was suppose to be wakana) lol
Personally I think this VN was rly bad drop in quality compared to kamimaho. Kamimaho was rly awesome, I believe the artist is same yet the quality drop amazes me, makes me doubt it's the same.
#10 by ryudb
2017-04-02 at 15:59
Is it? A 7.54 average seems to indicate it's considered to be at least good.
#11 by bdawg
2017-04-05 at 12:50
Story was good, but too predictable. Art was pretty bad compared to their prev work. Compare cg frm kamimaho to here.
#12 by p4izanagi
2017-11-30 at 10:44
imo the heroine routes is very bland.
#13 by funnerific
2019-03-04 at 12:33
A game with an exceptionally good common route and bland heroine routes, ruined by the true route. If it was just 4 regular routes or something and three of them were bad, I could still have loved the game, but when the true route is bad it kills the whole game. It's also the game which made me realize how bad island settings are and decide to avoid them from then on (because the island inevitably becomes a prison for the main cast or the stage of the plot, unrealistically isolated from the rest of the world).Last modified on 2019-03-04 at 12:41
#14 by kiru
2019-03-04 at 15:10
Island settings are good if handled well. That said, a lot of VNs just don't, because a lot of VNs are generally not good.
It's not really isolating stuff more than other settings either. Budget doesn't really allow for a lot of backgrounds, so you will always have insanely limited settings, unless you have a rare exception.

That said, there's not much you can expect from this writer other than double standards. If you mind that, it's pretty awful. And even if you don't, at some point it will likely collapse for even the most patient reader. Maybe he can fix it at some point. I'm doubting that though.

Reply

You must be logged in to reply to this thread.