A ProfileKinda not bad characters, kinda not bad story, typical Looseboy bullshity and canerous dramas on rather low levels. Few nice ideas, but butchered in a mawkish way. Overall - simply 'pageturner' without much substance.
Cartagra ~Tsuki Kurui no Yamai~So much potential, so very wasted. Awful characters (Kazuna ultimate mood-killer, Shugo dumbass horny deviant), awfully plotholed story, bad structure of scenario, awful romance (completly out-of-nowhere), and one of my worst VN experiences. Really good production value. Music, backgrounds, interface, some sprites.
Dengeki StrykerIs it juvenile? Yes. Is it cliched? Yes. Is it shallow? Yes. Then - is it good? Hell yes! Lots of fun, great cast of good written, tropey, but with really great presentation, characters, that are really enjoyable and playing off each other really well. A lot of nice comedy and really emotionall and impactfull action scenes.which mekes them enjoyable.
Eden* They Were Only Two, On The Planet.Fantastic atmosphere, simple, yet effective story, great presentation(art, animations, MUSIC!) and fine characters. Partly. Other part of cast was really ... bad. Good read, worthy of that 10 hours.
euphoriaPretty f*cked-up VN, with surprisingly great story, great writing, fantastic music, good characters (I hate Rika, but she was designet to be that annoying, which is great), and some inventive h-scenes. Good title.
Ever17 -The Out of Infinity-Boring, horribly paced, repetetive pseudo sf story, with uninteresting characters, terribly written routes and bad art. On a positive side it has a good setting, few interesting and good plot points, and cosy, not annoying for the most part atmosphere. It's not the worst thing ever, is not insulting, but still fairly bad. Not worth this 25 hours.
Fata morgana no YakataTruly the work of Art. Fantastic, multilayered melodrama, with incredibly rich and deep characters, great worldbuilding, eerie atmosphere and a lot of fantastic prose.
Grisaia no Kajitsu -Le Fruit de la Grisaia-It's not worst thing ever, but is fairly bad. Lot's of good ideas, burried by atrocious writting. And I don't mean prose - I mean story structure. Main writter never knows what to write, what to emphasize and what to shorten. Almost always makes bad choices in that regard. Pacing is horrible. Humour is only about dumb characters and their idiocy. At least not overlly vulgar, but still - not funny at all. Also - average art, generic soundtrack. Would not recommend to anybody. Waste of 65+ hours.
Grisaia no YuukanAbsolute garbage. Only for idiots. I mean - Grisaia fans. And hard ons, because it's even worse than Kajitsu common route. Jokes(?) are unfunny as hell, Michiru stupidity is enlarged and above all - Yumiko is made as simply horny, yet embarassed bitch. One of two CGs is very meh, and other looks like totall garbage.
G-senjou no MaouOne of the greatest tension-wise, not so great character-wise. Very good read, not very flawed, but it's simply not a masterpeice. ~Yuki deserved a painfull death.
HimawariIt would be a really good VN, if it would be like last two 'Afterstories'. Much better written, much more intersting characters, (shitty graphics in only ~5 CGs, no sprites at all), much better themes and ideas , which was completly absent in "main" story (which is ridiculous, whole structure of this VN is very jumbled). Overall it's a waste of time. Not really 'different' from 'regular' charage, interesting setting is completly unutilized, characters are awfull(Aqua) to not intersting(Aries in 2048) at best and it have single one most terrible character I ever witness. Chinami from Hoshizora? Pff. Kazuna from Cartagra? Not even close. Touka from Sharin no Kuni? Okey, she's close, but only close. Ladies and gentlemen I present to you Amamiya Daigo. Worst. Character. Ever. I must also add that terribly moe graphics is terrible and not fitting to story at all, which dimnishes the enjoyment even more.
HitomeboreNo plot, cardboard characters, bad music, weakly written romance and kinda nice and unique visual style. Not offensive, but just bad title.
Homeless Joshi ***GakuseiReally great text presentation, and fxes, but zero plot. Only series untintended hilarious scenes, whichc shortly gets repetetive and boring.
Hoshizora no Memoria -Wish upon a Shooting Star-Most;ly boring, painfull, cancer-giving, with ultra-stupid dramas (Asuho! Isuzu!), horrible, horrible characters (Chinami), terrible romance/h-scenes ideas (Mare and Chinami...), and really stupid, bad written, unlogicall true route with annoying heroine. Only twins had a nice routes, but nothing worthy of interest.
Ikinari Anata ni KoishiteiruI like it much more than I should. Nice common route with absolutely GREAT horror fragment, great Tane route, and rest is from 'really bad' to 'meh' at most.
I/OOne of the rare 1st league VNs. Minor nitpicking - too much 'tropey' characters (tsunderism, moeism etc), sometimes cheesy scenes and few problems with pacing. Biggest flaw - construction. Too much routes and too much 'reading' them on skip almot entirely for few additional scenes, necessary too move on to another route. Rest of it is awesome. Story, themes, presentation, music, technical aspects, and even art have quality in it. Full spectrum of emotions, almost like in MLA.