Baldr Sky Dive1 “Lost Memory”Cool setting, likable characters, fun gameplay, interesting plot twists, decent pacing for its length. Can be a bit repetitive and has a few unnecessarily dumb edgey scenes.
Baldr Sky Dive2 “Recordare”First 2 routes could have been better but had interesting moments. Last 2 routes were quite interesting but not amazing. Main flaws were repetitiveness and not building up certain things well. Otherwise pretty enjoyable.
Canvas 2 ~Akaneiro no Palette~Half the heroines were annoying as hell. Protag being a teacher was weird outside dating people his age. Saya and Tomoko were the only consistently decent enough characters.
Chaos;HeadHopefully an eventual official release fixes the technical problems I had.
ClannadThe routes that didn't make the anime were pretty nice. Didn't have motivation to read the last few ones that are already in anime. Sunohara was somehow more hilarious in the VN.
Coμ - Kuroi Ryuu to Yasashii Oukoku -Strangely inconsistent. Has some good moments but also some anticlimatic moments too. Akihito is pretty lame. Some of the side characters are forgettable. Most of the main girls are likable enough thankfully. The best routes were probably the charage routes honestly.
Cross†ChannelSome interesting fucked up people. A few characters weren't so likable but the interesting characters were enough to make up for it.
d2b VS Deardrops -Cross the Future-Amazing crossover. Kira Kira characters with updated art looked really damn good. Characters from both series interacted and it was done pretty well. It was great having both series follow their true routes and it was cool to see problems that weren't fully solved get talked about, especially Kira Kira's true route ending. Focused too much on Riho's negative points and not enough on supporting characters sadly.
DeardropsRiho's extreme honesty really intrigued me. Every major character was likable. Two routes were really good. Two routes were.. alright I guess.
Dengeki StrykerTried multiple times. I got to Ch 5. I just dont care about all these characters they keep rushing in. Action is meh. A few waifus I kinda care about but not enough to carry the whole experience.
Dies iraeDecent characters and plot concept marred by crappy pacing, crappy romance, and main villains that succumb to pretentious writing and dont ever shut the fuck up about shit.
Dracu-Riot!An actual solid story and some characters ruined by terrible anti-MC humor. Elina was the one consistent saving grace.
Dra†KoII still have no idea what I was supposed to get out of this story outside complete randomness and a forceful heroine.
EdelweissIncredibly hilarious common route with surprisingly good feels and friendship scenes. Wasn't really big on any of the actual routes. Mizuki was probably the best I guess? Even though she was probs my least favorite heroine personality-wise.
Edelweiss Eiden FantasiaRin's route was pretty dumb which sucks because she was actually good in the route. Sakura's route was decent if kinda melodramatic. "True" route was hot.
Ever17 -The Out of Infinity-I really did not like how the ending was done. Which sucks because I really like just about everything else. Every route was good, every character (besides Coco) was good, the drama was good, the character development was good, the mindfuckness and atmosphere was excellently done.
Fate/Stay NightFate is good but Shirou too white knight. UBW is somewhat overrated but still kinda good. HF da bess. All Heroines are good. Sakura da bess
Fureraba ~Friend to Lover~Standard moege romance stuff but with a funny MC, a surprisingly likable tsundere, and a cool down to earth waifu make up for boring childhood friend, and dating/sexing someone with legit childlike innocence
Grisaia no Kajitsu -Le Fruit de la Grisaia-Have not finished Makina and Michiru routes. VN is way too slow paced a lot of the time. There's also some weird over the top drama. Comedy is pretty funny and there's some sweet moments and character development that overall makes it worth.
Higurashi no Naku Koro ni KaiI only read Chapter 5 (not even sure if I read it all). Cool to see more of Shion's PoV and stuff not in the anime. But mostly satisfied enough with anime content to not see more.
Hoshizora no Memoria -Wish upon a Shooting Star-Every route was good even if every heroine wasn't necessarily good. Some humor was annoying and repetitive and some was hilarious. Some pretty good drama, romance and character development. True route was really good. Asuho one of my top waifus.
I/OSome of the most inconsistent routes ever. A was slow but slowly got interesting. B was kinda good. C and D were unnecssarily confusing as fuck. E was good then weird. A' and B' were interesting enough epilogues. C' and D' I kinda sorta liked them I guess? E' was uhh k den. Also very few likable characters best one was Ishtar.
IxSHE TellI liked the idea of all the girls liking MC from start, but the humor style with it was pretty stupid.
Kanojo to Ore to Koibito to.The hooking up in common route thing was interesting, but every heroine besides main girl was fuckin annoying ESPECIALLY the tsundere
Katawa ShoujoJust about every character is likable though Shizune is debatable. All routes were good sans Shizune which one again is debatable. Emi would be a top tier waifu if her 'casual talk' was toned down a bit.
Kikokugai - The Cyber SlayerRuili's story was interesting and the plot twist was amusing. Fights could have been paced better. There could have been more likable characters.