the visual novel database

Report an issue on this page.

Review of Hirahira Hihiru

SubjectHirahira Hihiru
Hirahira Hihiru
ByHelpfulness: 0
Vote: 2
miek on 2024-09-04
ReviewAn unplesant voyeuristic torture porn-story featuring some of the most sterile prose that is brimming with pointless anecdotes parading as worldbuilding, dry infodump monologues that do a lot of telling instead of showing, in which the reader is constantly berrated with surface-level platitudes about society and healthcare. Also turns into a slice of life loony bin simulator halfway through which is distasteful.

Fundamentally disingenuous as it cannot commit on its subject matter and instead attempts to tug at heartstrings with unsavory and cartoonish drama, where the weazel author had to come up with a supernatural disease turning people into living-deads in order to avoid tackling the causality of mental illness.

''Hihirus'' are described as being incurable reanimated corpses, roaming city streets in a state of confused stupor, emanating a foul stench of putrid carrion and decaying flesh which attract swarms of flies. The narration makes sure the reader understand that Hihirus are rowdy and like to play with their own excrements.

This is where the storytelling falls flat on its face: Hihiru zombies are acting as dangerous sanitary health hazards everywhere they go and due to this very fact, there is not a single ounce of empathy to be had towards them no matter how well-spoken they may appear to be at first, for they are seconds away from clawing at their own faces or hallucinating dead people or insects.

There is no real-life equivalent and compromise to be had when the premise of the story is this flawed: the author made sure to justify the discrimination and intolerance towards such monsters every step of the way which is deceitful and outright offensive.

On the bright side, the sassy tomboy photographer was cute and deserves her own game.

Go read Johnny Got His Gun written by Dalton Trumbo instead for a genuine anti-establishment commentary against the unruly state of healthcare and society.
0 points
#1 by SkankinGarbage
2024-09-04 at 09:58
< report >Weirdly enough, saying that this novel is "Johnny Got His Gun but shittier" makes me wanna play it in spite of myself - that's an all-time favorite of mine. Although, I don't think Johnny Got His Gun had anything significant to say about healthcare.
#2 by cheekyman07
2024-09-05 at 10:44
< report >#OP
They don't justify discrimination every step of the way. The author presents it as an unjust obstacle (as you stated). Then presents a cast fighting against it, and that is displayed the most in the last third. Working against discrimination was the whole point, to state the author is for discrimination and intolerance is ridiculous, and the opposite. That's just one questionable point, but I'll stop here since I don't want to write an essay.

#1 
I'm fine if someone does not like something so long as the points/opinions hold water, but this reviewer makes several false absolute statements about the VN that IMO are pretty misleading. If you are thinking of reading this Skankin, please consider the other reviews here as well.Last modified on 2024-09-05 at 11:48
#3 by SkankinGarbage
2024-09-05 at 12:06
< report >#2 Don't sweat it, I've been interested in reading more of Setoguchi's works ever since Musicus became a fast favorite of mine, so I'm certain I'll read it eventually. I just found the comparison between this VN and one of my favorite novels intriguing - especially because the reviewer says that the novel contains "anti-establishment commentary against the unruly state of healthcare and society"...which, y'know. Johnny Got His Gun has a very powerful, pointed message...but not about that, lol.Last modified on 2024-09-05 at 12:08
#4 by cheekyman07
2024-09-05 at 12:33
< report >#3
I mean, the reviewer is not wrong about the message. It does present those and is set in a past period. As such society in this setting has less basic medical knowledge and understanding. So of course you have all sorts of backwards years past discrimination and other awful shit, that to us looks horrible. I have not read that title, so I'll take your word for it, you got me curious about it too.Last modified on 2024-09-05 at 12:39