the visual novel database

Report an issue on this page.

Review of soundless - A MODERN SALEM IN REMOTE AREA -

Subjectsoundless - A MODERN SALEM IN REMOTE AREA -
soundless - A MODERN SALEM IN REMOTE AREA - Version 2.0
ByHelpfulness: 0
Vote: 7
henrietta on 2022-01-15 last updated on 2022-01-16
ReviewI saw this in the denpa tag & decided to give it a read since it was rated pretty well, I try not to pay too much mind to ratings when I pick something up but this one took me by surprise; Around 4h in I was wondering how much longer it was going to go on for & eventually dropped it a short while later, bout a year later now & I've finished it & I still sorta feel about the same way I did before, but I am honestly glad I stuck it thru.

This is in no way to say that I think this is all bad btw, it's really clear that this is their first big project & honestly I am really impressed, the parts that (in my opinion) were the strongest were really strong & really captivated me & made me want to read more, some other sections though dragged on for far too long to the point it felt aggravating & unnecessary & made me lose focus

Despite these complaints it really only got better the more it went on -- I didn't care much for Mercy at all, but I could really feel for her confusion with her faith & her own personal feelings, towards herself, towards the town, towards the God that was supposed to be looking after her, it really hit hard. Mercy also struggling with her (what I assumed to be) romantic feelings towards Delilah & Auma while also struggling with being paranoid over their true intentions hit hard for me too. I think this depiction of insidious gaslighting, heavy abuse & Stockholm syndrome were done really well & it really left me feeling deep sadness for Mercy while she was caught up in its cycle.
EDIT: Especially now after reading authors notes, I really think this was done beautifully & it was the strongest part of this for me, the more I think back on Soundless the more I really love it & the more blown away I am; Mercy's mindset & Auma's narcissism perpetuating a perverted cycle felt all too real & makes me really glad I came back to finish it.


That being said, I still feel unsure where I stand on this, & I haven't read the "bonus content" which I assume is something regarding something Auma mentions briefly near the latter half, but I don't feel all that compelled to read it - I am however really excited to read more from milk+ because I think it only goes uphill from here, I'm really looking forward to Polychromania & I'll definitely check out 7388; I'll need to be pointed in the right direction when it comes to looking for yuri content, but I almost never see it done well, that's another thing I want 2 compliment in this case ^^

This is all without mentioning how it handles individuals who struggle with being isolated due to having a mental illness/not being able to adjust & properly mask to fit in with other people, honestly the more I think on it the more it's creating a really soft spot in my heart

This was a really sweet project & I'm glad its out there

EDIT: i initially rated this ~4 & then came back & rated it 6, but i really think this is really cool/worth checking out, the end & the post-content sold me; I said I didn't finish the bonus content up there but it's definitely worth the read now that i've finished it all, this is really special
0 points
#1 by onorub
2022-01-15 at 23:03
< report >Wait, you didn't read the post-game logs? They actually explain what exactly happened in the story.
#2 by henrietta
2022-01-15 at 23:50
< report >@onorub I just finished reading them - I still feel the same but it solidifies how I feel about it I think, I really admire all the care that went into it & I think the plot going on behind the scenes is really interesting too, thought it was becoming one of those typical-meta-type-narratives, but this is really interesting & answers everything in a satisfying way, the Head Priest being behind this micro-society kinda made me roll my eyes initially, but seeing him get sucked into this world he "created" & killed by it was really cool, these logs sort-of loosely reminded me of "One Shot in the Dark, Now I'm Dead." which I also enjoyed & wish there were more of - I think on its own it ends nicely but the post-game logs were the bow on the present 4 sureLast modified on 2022-01-15 at 23:50